Participant Experience in a Study of Dietary Counselling plus Omega-3 Supplementation for the Treatment of Generalized Anxiety Disorder among Women: A Focus Group Study.

Save

Abstract

Introduction

Nutrition is an important determinant of health among people with mental disorders; however, barriers to dietary counselling exist. The Eating and Supplementation for Generalized Anxiety Disorder study (“EASe-GAD”) was the first trial to assess the impact of these interventions on anxiety symptoms. The primary objective of the present companion qualitative study was to gather and analyze qualitative data about the acceptability, participant experience, impact, barriers and facilitators, strengths, and weaknesses of the EASe-GAD program while also identifying opportunities for improvement.

Methods

Participants were eligible for this study if they participated in the EASe-GAD trial. Data were collected using focus groups which followed a semi-structured interview approach with a set of predetermined questions. The sessions were recorded and transcribed for data analysis.

Data were analyzed by thematic analysis.

Results

Three focus groups were completed, involving a total of 12 women. They reported a range of components that they found helpful, such as increased self-efficacy, as well as positive outcomes that they attributed to the intervention, such as improved mental and physical health. They reported components of the program that were less enjoyable, such as having their body weight measured, and also suggested opportunities for improvement.

Many participants reported that cost implications of a diet intervention were an important consideration.

Conclusion

This project provided valuable insight into the participant experience and impact of the pilot dietary counselling program. Participants reported benefits and opportunities for improvement for subsequent studies aimed at improving nutrition among people with anxiety disorders.

Introduction

Generalized anxiety disorder (GAD) is a common mental disorder that presents with excessive worry and tension that can make it difficult and distressing to participate in day-to-day events [1]. In Canada, 8.7% of people experience GAD in their lifetime [2]. To meet the criteria for a diagnosis of GAD, symptoms must be present most days for at least 6 months; they must interfere with an individual’s functioning and exert a negative impact on quality of life [1, 3].

Treatment options are available for GAD and include pharmacotherapy and psychotherapy; however, these interventions are not always effective. Many patients report them to be intolerable, ineffective, or inaccessible [4]. The percentage of patients that are treated adequately for GAD is estimated to be as low at 20–32% [4, 5].

Overall, GAD results in a high personal cost as well as a social cost; there is a need for adjunctive treatment options.

There is a growing body of evidence that suggests that nutrition is a modifiable risk factor for mental disorders [6]. While there is significant evidence suggesting an antidepressant effect of dietary counselling [7], the research on diet change as a treatment for anxiety disorders is less established. Recent randomized controlled trials with participants with depressive disorders have shown a statistically significant improvement in symptoms of depression following improved dietary quality based on the Mediterranean diet [8–11] or omega-3 fatty acid supplementation in combination with dietary changes [12].

The effect diet has on physical health is well established. Among people with mental disorders, there is a significant reduction in life expectancy [13, 14], attributed largely to increased rates of chronic illnesses such as diabetes and cardiovascular disease. Risk factors such as obesity, physical inactivity, and poor nutrition play a role.

A recent systematic review reported that dietary counselling interventions can have a positive impact on dietary habits among people with mental disorders and that lifestyle counselling can have a positive impact on weight, body mass index, and waist circumference [15]. It is recognized that factors such as motivation, medication effects, and socioeconomic factors can influence the success of diet change among people with mental illnesses. While barriers to diet change have been identified among individuals with serious mental illness [16–18], less is known about these among people with anxiety disorders and the most appropriate strategies for facilitating diet change in this population.

The Eating and Supplementation for Generalized Anxiety Disorder study (“EASe-GAD”) was the first clinical trial to assess the impact of dietary counselling on symptoms of anxiety among women diagnosed with GAD. This randomized, wait-list controlled pilot trial provided 12 weeks of biweekly dietary counselling and an omega-3 supplement (3,456 mg per day containing 2,660 mg eicosapentaenoic acid and 532 mg docosahexanaeoic acid) to 50 adults women with moderate-to-severe GAD. It assessed the acceptability and feasibility of this intervention as well as the impact on anxiety symptoms (using the Beck Anxiety Inventory) and other outcomes [19, 20].

The current manuscript presents the results of a companion qualitative study exploring participant experiences from the EASe-GAD trial.

Methods

Objectives

The primary objective of this study was to gather and analyze qualitative data about the acceptability, participant experience, impact, strengths, and weaknesses of the EASe-GAD intervention, while also identifying opportunities for improvement for subsequent larger scale delivery.

Study Design and Setting

This project recruited participants from the EASe-GAD pilot study to participate in focus groups designed to collect qualitative data on their experience in the trial. The interpretive framework used was pragmatism as the main goal of the study was to capture data that can be used to improve subsequent follow-up studies [21]. This project was reviewed and overseen by the Research Ethics Board of the Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine (CCNMREB052.Aucoin).

Participants’ Eligibility

Inclusion criteria for the focus group study were as follows:1.Previously enrolled in the EASe-GAD pilot study2.Consent granted for the researchers to contact regarding follow-up studies

A detailed description of the EASe-GAD participants is previously reported; however, to briefly summarize, these were adults who self-reported female gender identity and female biological sex, with moderate-to-severe generalized anxiety disorder at baseline. They had suboptimal baseline diet quality and OmegaScore, a blood-based marker of essential fatty acids. Other treatments (such as medication, psychotherapy, or natural health products) for anxiety were stable.

The mean age of EASe-GAD participants was 37 years (SD: 12), and they were most frequently employed, white, and university educated [19, 20]. Participants were eligible to participate in the qualitative component of the study regardless of their study visit attendance, intervention compliance, or study outcomes as one means to minimize sampling bias.

Sample Size

We aimed to recruit 8–18 participants to run 2–4 focus groups, each having 4–6 participants. The process of achieving sample size was designed to be iterative based on saturation of categorical themes. This process was defined a priori, and based on standard guidance on approaches to sample size determination in qualitative research [22].

After the first focus group, we completed a brief analysis and identified themes. After the second group, the same analysis was done to see if new themes were identified. Because new themes were identified, a third focus group was completed.

When reviewing the data from the third group, no new themes were identified, thus our threshold for data saturation was reached, our stopping rule for achieving sample size was met, and data collection was complete.

Procedure

Eligible participants were contacted by email and invited to participate. Invitations were sent 2 months after completion of the EASe-GAD study. If they responded that they were interested in participating in the focus group, an informed consent form was be sent via email for review and a set of available times to schedule a discussion with the study coordinator to complete the informed consent process and documentation.

Once informed consent was obtained, participants were scheduled for an upcoming focus group based on their availability. Focus groups were conducted using the Zoom Professional platform in order to minimize participant time/travel and to facilitate safeguards for data protection and privacy. Each focus group was run by the same member of the EASe-GAD investigator team who had no previous contact with any study participants (K.C.).

The lead researcher (M.A.) who delivered the dietary counselling program was not present at the focus groups.

The focus groups lasted 60–90 min in length. Consistent with semi-structured interview methodology, a set of predefined questions (online supplemental file 1; for all online suppl. material, see https://doi.org/10.1159/000550697) was asked of the participants, with opportunity to expand on the question set or follow-up on new themes. The sessions ended after 90 min even if all of the questions were not asked.

The sessions were recorded and transcribed for data analysis purposes. Transcription was facilitated using the Zoom function (draft) and then checked for accuracy against audio recordings twice by the study coordinator.

Data Analysis

Transcribed data from all three focus group sessions were analyzed by inductive thematic analysis [23] using two different approaches. One of the approaches was a direct question analysis to assess for certain responses or themes that were presented when individuals answered questions. Additionally, a general thematic analysis was done to identify themes that were present across the entire collected dataset.

Results

Twenty individuals expressed interest in participating; informed consent was provided by 15. Three participants did not attend their scheduled focus group. A total of 12 individuals participated in one of three focus groups held between October and November of 2023.

There were four participants in each focus group. Demographic information, outcome, and satisfaction data for the focus group participants is presented in Table 1; the demographics of the focus group participants are similar to those of the EASe-GAD pilot study participants. Although the final anxiety score appeared to be slightly lower in the focus group participants (mean BAI 16.3; SD 13.7) compared to the pilot study participants (18.9; SD 12.4), this appears to be a small difference.

Similarly, the satisfaction score was 4.92 (SD 0.29) among the focus group participants compared to 4.89 (SD 0.31) among the pilot study participants.

Six themes emerged from the data which are presented in Figures 1–6. These included the program benefits, negative impacts, barriers, facilitators, cost considerations, and suggestions for improvement.

Benefits

Many participants reported a range of benefits that they attributed to participation in the intervention (Fig. 1). These included a number of health changes such as improvement in mental and physical health, a decrease in stress, as well as health benefits among family members who also made changes to their diet, and continued health benefits beyond the study period.

Participants reported an increase in self-efficacy, including higher motivation and a sense of pride or accomplishment from cooking.

Many participants reported learning about a wide range of topics related to nutrition, cooking, and reading labels. They reported learning about the impact of food on mental health and the impact of food on health beyond the usual focus on weight. They also reported an increase in self-awareness about their eating behaviors.

Other benefits reported included improved eating behavior such as eating at more regular intervals, eating more slowly, and less mindless eating. Participants reported improved diet quality and variety, increased enjoyment of food, and decreased food waste.

Negative Impacts

Participants reported negative impacts of participating in the study as well (Fig. 2). They reported increased burden from commuting to in-person visits.

They also reported a burden related to creating new habits as effort was required. They reported that some of the recommended foods were higher in cost. These themes are reported in detail in a subsequent subsection.

Some participants reported frustration related to the process of reporting incidental abnormal blood test results to their primary health care provider. The intervention deliverer did not report the abnormal finding directly to the participant and some participants reported frustration with this process.

One participant reported a concern that tracking diet closely could precipitate an eating disorder among individuals who were prone to these conditions.

Some reported adverse events attributed to the omega-3 supplement, such as heart burn or digestive upset, or difficulty swallowing the large capsules. Lastly, several participants reported concerns about having their body weight measured as part of the study procedures. They described the process as unpleasant.

Having been told that the intervention was meant to improve diet quality and not to impact body weight, they reported that having their weight measured was confusing, incongruent with the messaging, and provided false hope.

Barriers

Participants identified several barriers that impacted their ability to adjust their eating and supplementation habits according to the study recommendations (Fig. 3). One commonly cited barrier was time, including the time spent planning meals, shopping, preparing food, learning new recipes, and practicing mindful eating.

It was noted by participants that the time burden decreased as the new habits developed and that they felt the benefits they received justified the time investment.

Other barriers included difficulty transporting the provided food home from the study visits and storing food at home.

Others reported that the size of the omega-3 capsules was a barrier.

Cravings were cited as a barrier to changing diet habits by some participants. Some described their relationship with certain foods as an addiction.

Others reported difficulty changing longstanding habits around foods such as the types of foods eaten and eating behaviors.

Lastly, some participants identified factors related to their social or living circumstances as impeding their uptake of the recommendation. They commented on the difficulty of having to make multiple meals in order to accommodate different food preferences.

Other participants reported less control over their ability to make diet changes when other family members took a larger role in the acquisition and preparation of food. Some reported pressure to eat certain foods in certain social situations while others reported temptation from seeing family members eating the foods that they were attempting to eat less often.

Facilitators

On the other hand, participants reported many facilitators which assisted with incorporating the study recommendations (Fig. 4). Many participants found the skills that were learned and the resources that were provided as part of the dietary counselling to be helpful.

These included recipes, strategies for bulk food preparation and strategies for managing non-hunger cravings for food.

Many participants reported that the aspects of the dietary counselling that they found most helpful included support, individualization, and flexibility.

Cost Considerations

One prominent theme that emerged was the importance of considering the cost of a dietary intervention. Figure 5 displays themes that emerged. Participants reported that the cost impact of the dietary intervention was complex with some healthier foods being more expensive and some less expensive compared to the foods they were previously eating.

Several participants reported that their overall spending did not increase while some reported an overall saving, often attributed to eating less restaurant and takeout food.

Participants also reported that they adjusted their shopping habits in order to change their food purchases without impacting their total spending.

Suggestions for improvement participants suggested several areas that they felt could be improved in subsequent studies (Fig. 6). A means of tracking use/dosing of the omega-3 supplement to reduce missed doses was of interest.

While some participants appreciated the study website which housed the study resources and handouts, some expressed a preference for receiving a paper copy of these. There was an interest in both long-term follow-up and/or an email newsletter that could serve as ongoing support to maintain aspects of the study after the intervention.

Some participants expressed an interest in group sessions or teaching kitchen components as part of the intervention in order to have hands-on learning about food preparation.

Discussion

Focus group participants provided rich insights of the participant experience in the EASe-GAD pilot study. They reported a range of benefits that they attributed to participation as well as a variety of components that they found helpful. They reported components of the program that were less enjoyable and opportunities for improvement.

Many participants reported that cost implications of a diet intervention were an important consideration, and that measuring participant body weight had unintended consequences. They reported barriers and facilitators to following the study recommendations. All of these factors can be considered in the design of subsequent trials aimed at providing dietary counselling to people with GAD and provide meaningful context to the outcomes of the EASe-GAD pilot study.

The findings of this study are consistent with other qualitative data about participant experience in dietary intervention studies. In a similar qualitative study of women with obesity receiving a diet intervention, participants reported that social situations and pressure were a significant factor in maintaining diet change [24]. A study of adults receiving a dietary intervention for nonalcoholic fatty liver disease reported that convenience was a key factor in influencing diet habits [25].

Similar to participants in the present study, they also reported that goal setting, and provision of food hampers and educational resources were key intervention components. Other studies have reported on the importance of goal setting and resources such as handouts and recipes in various mediums [26, 27]. Barriers cited in the present study have also been reported previously [28], including the perception of increased cost of healthy food and time for meal preparation [29, 30].

A previous qualitative focus group study by Lee et al. [31] gathered feedback about the relationship between food and mental health. The first key theme reported in this study was the bidirectional nature of the relationship between food and mental health, particularly the tendency for eating in response to negative emotions. This was also highlighted by participants in our study with an emphasis on the importance to bringing more attention to eating behaviors, particularly those that were driven by negative emotions rather than hunger, and the usefulness of resources and strategies to navigate non-hunger cravings for food.

A second theme highlighted in the Lee et al. [31] study was the need for individuality and the diverse nutritional needs of different people. Participants in our study similarly highlighted an appreciation for individualization. Lastly, the previous study reported a theme related to removing food restriction and weight-focused thinking and focusing on eating mindfully and intuitively.

Similarly, our study participants commented on the value of having participant-generate goals and appreciated the fact that the recommendations provided were not restrictive. All of the study recommendations and the goals that participants set focused on the inclusion of more of the foods consistent with the Mediterranean diet and not on the exclusion or elimination of any foods; there was no mention of calories or portion sizes. Participants received messaging that weight loss was not the goal of the intervention, directly during intervention delivery; however, the data from this qualitative study highlights that measurement of body weight may have undermined that message.

Body weight was measured, as it was in a similar previous study [8], with the intention of demonstrating that weight loss was not a confounding variable contributing to mental health benefit. However, unintended consequences of this study component such as confusion, false hope, and discomfort were noted in the present study. Other themes reported in a subsequent publication from the Lee et al. [32] focus group included the key role of the social context, social economics like time and finances as well as food nostalgia – all of which were highlighted in the present study.

The results of this qualitative study suggest that several components of the intervention were viewed as helpful by the participants and should be employed in subsequent studies aiming to improve diet quality among individuals with anxiety disorders. These include nutrition education, strategies for behavior change, food hampers, individualized support, and resources such as recipes. There were also components highlighted that could be opportunities for improvement.

These include offering print copies of all recourses for participants who preferred not to access them electronically, and providing a tool for participants to track their use of the supplement to help avoid mistakes in dosing. The data suggest that careful consideration about the necessity of measuring body weight is warranted. The frustration expressed about reporting incidental lab findings suggests that lab testing should be kept to a minimum and that expectations about handling abnormal findings should be further emphasized in the consent process.

The high level of interest in the cost implications of this intervention suggests that this is a highly important consideration and one that warrants formal evaluation in subsequent studies. Other intervention components, such as teaching kitchen or group session, newsletters, or long-term follow-up, warrant consideration. Lastly, the data on barriers and facilitators could be used to further refine the behavior change support provided to participants in an effort to maximize facilitators and support participants in effectively navigating known barriers.

This project had several strengths. It used a semi-structured interview to ensure that participants were queried about the same topics but allowed for follow-up and clarification of the responses provided. The focus group was repeated in order to achieve data saturation.

This project also had limitations. Because the population reflected the participants in the EASe-GAD pilot trial, only women living in a Canadian urban setting were included. The participant experience and needs of others, including diverse genders, or people living in different settings may be different compared to those captured in this study.

Although we did not find evidence of a difference in satisfaction scores between those who participated in the focus group and those who completed the EASe-GAD pilot trial, it is possible that those who experienced more benefit were more willing to participate in the focus group; this could introduce selection bias. Other limitations inherent to a focus group approach may have exerted an influence on the study findings such as an impact of a dominant voice or social desirability bias. The range of heterogenous responses collected in this project suggest that these factors may not have substantially influenced the study findings; however, some degree of impact is possible [33, 34].

Conclusion

Nutrition is an important modifiable risk factor impacting physical health outcomes among people with mental disorders. Emerging evidence from the EASe-GAD trial suggests that dietary counselling may also improve the symptoms of mental health disorder such as GAD. This project provided valuable insight into the participant experience and impact of the pilot dietary counselling program.

Participants reported benefits of the program as well as less enjoyable components and suggestions for improvement. These findings provide both as context for the findings of the EASe-GAD pilot trial and inform the design of subsequent clinical trials delivering a dietary counselling and nutrient supplementation intervention to adult women with generalized anxiety disorder.

Acknowledgments

The authors wish to thank our participants for contributing to this research by sharing their experiences.

Statement of Ethics

This study was performed in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki, and conducted in accordance with principles outlined in the Tri-Council Policy Statement: Ethical Conduct for Research Involving Humans – TCPS 2 (2022). This human study was approved by the Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine – approval: CCNMREB052.Aucoin. All participants were of adult age and provided written informed consent to participate in this study.

Conflict of Interest Statement

None of the authors have a conflict of interest. None of the authors have any financial disclosures to declare.

Funding Sources

This research project received funding from the Ekhagastiftelsen Foundation (Grant #2021-75). The funders had no role in the design, conduct, analysis, or reporting of this research.

Author Contributions

M. Aucoin, L. LaChance, and K.

Cooley equally contributed to the conception and design of this research. K. Cooley and D.

Barbaro contributed to the acquisition of data. M. Aucoin, D.

Barbaro, and L. LaChance contributed to the analysis of data. M.

Aucoin and D. Barbaro drafted the manuscript. All authors critically revised the manuscript, agree to be fully accountable for ensuring the integrity and accuracy of the work, and read and approved the final manuscript.

Related articles

PubMed

Resting-State EEG Spectral Power in Young Adults With Generalized Anxiety Disorder and Self-Reported Habitual Short Sleep: A Case-Control Study.

ABSTRACT Background Generalized anxiety disorder (GAD) and insufficient sleep frequently co‐occur during early adulthood, yet resting‐state electroencephalographic (EEG) evidence in this population remains limited. The present study aimed to characterize resting‐state EEG spectral power in young adults with GAD who also reported habitual short sleep, compared with healthy controls. Methods This exploratory case‐control study included 56 university students: 28 participants with GAD and self‐...

PubMed

Increased Serum TNF-α Levels Are Associated With Generalized Anxiety Disorder: A Case-Control Study.

ABSTRACT Background and Aims Generalized anxiety disorder (GAD) is a mental health disorder that affects many people in all aspects of their lives. It is characterized by persistent and excessive worry that the affected person finds difficult to control. The actual pathophysiology and mechanisms underlying GAD are still elusive. However, cytokines and cell signaling proteins are hypothesized to contribute to the pathogenesis of anxiety. The present study aimed to understand the association of...